Tioga Menu

Family-owned & operated since 2004

Download Our Menu Order Online

Salads & Small Plates

We use local organic greens when available and in season. Our dressings are all made in house using extra virgin olive oil, and top quality vinegars, cheese and herbs

  • Herbed Tuscan Fries

    Parmesan and herb seasoned crispy fries, served with house-made peppadew tomato jam, lemon aioli

    $7.50

  • Highway Parmesan Cheese Bread

    Fresh from the oven flatbread, rosemary, garlic, Parmesan, Asiago, Romano. Served with marinara

    $11.00

  • Bruschetta

    Our house-made toasted focaccia, vine ripe plum tomatoes, garlic, basil, balsamic, extra virgin olive oil, topped with shaved Grana Padano

    $11.00

  • Brie & Spinach Flatbread

    Spinach, Brie, bacon, roasted red onion, balsamic glaze on a crispy flatbread

    $14.00

  • Antipasti Plate

    Assortment of meats, cheeses, olives, roasted vegetables, Tuscan hummus, toasted focaccia

    $16.00

  • Blue Highway Wings

    Crispy fried chicken wings or tempeh tossed in Buffalo, BBQ or Dragonfire sauce. Served with house-made Gorgonzola or buttermilk ranch. Carrots and celery sticks upon request

    Market Price

  • Bomba Shrimp

    Crispy fried shrimp tossed in a sweet & spicy Calabrian sauce. Served over a bed of arugula

    $13.50

  • Fried Calamari

    Crispy fried U.S. caught calamari, marinara sauce

    $14.50

  • Tuscan Hummus

    Tuscan white beans pureed with tahini, garlic, lemon and spices. Served with warm flatbread and fresh cut vegetables

    $11.00

  • Micanopy Salad

    Fresh garden greens, carrots, grape tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions

    $10.5(L), $7.5(S)

  • Classic Caesar

    Crisp romaine hearts, shaved Grana Padano, house-made croutons, Caesar dressing

    $12.5(L), $8.5(S)

  • Blue Highway Salad

    Fresh garden greens, feta, grape tomatoes, red onions, Kalamata olives, toasted pecans

    $12.5(L), $8.5(S)

  • Tuscan Bean Salad

    Fresh spinach, cannellini beans, sun-dried tomatoes, roasted red onions, olives, feta, lemon vinaigrette

    $12.5(L), $8.5(S)

Sandwiches & Piadines

Our sandwiches are made on fresh baked focaccia or try our Piadines

(Can be made GF for an additional 3)

  • Roast Turkey Club

    Roast turkey breast, bacon, provolone, lettuce, tomato, roasted garlic aioli

    $14.00

  • The Highway

    Roast beef, roasted red onion, Vermont white cheddar and tangy horseradish sauce

    $14.00

  • The Gino (named after my dad)

    Genoa salami, capicola, provolone, lettuce, tomato, banana peppers and red wine vinaigrette

    $14.00

  • Apple Pecan Chicken Salad Sandwich

    Roasted chicken, apple, pecans, sun-dried cherries, and onion, with lettuce, tomato, dijonnaise on toasted focaccia

    $14.00

  • Chicken Rustico Panini

    Roast chicken breast, provolone, spinach and sun-dried tomato aioli

    $14.00

  • The Incredible Hot Tuna

    Our classic albacore tuna salad on toasted focaccia, provolone, crispy fried onions, tomato and honey dill mayo

    $15.00

  • Turkey Piadine

    Roast turkey breast, pesto aioli, mixed greens, red onion, feta, Parmesan, red wine vinaigrette

    $15.00

  • Tuscan Bean Piadine

    Tuscan hummus, spinach, Parmesan, Tuscan bean salad mix, feta, lemon vinaigrette

    $15.00

  • Lamb Piadine

    Roasted lamb, mint pesto aioli, mixed greens, red onion, feta, Parmesan, red wine vinaigrette

    $17.00

  • Parma Piadine

    Prosciutto, arugula, extra virgin olive oil, balsamic glaze, fresh mozzarella, Parmesan, bruschetta tomatoes

    $17.00

Specialty Pizzas

Our breads, pizzas and calzones all start the same way. A combination of flours, fresh yeast, sea salt, olive oil and water are mixed until a perfect dough is born. That living mixture is allowed to rest for 24 hours, growing and developing the rich flavor you will taste in the finished product. Then our Pizzaiolos hand toss each pizza to order.

* (HT) Hand Tossed (P) Pizzetta, (S) Sicillian

  • Margherita Pizza

    House-made pizza sauce, Parmesan, Romano, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil

    $14.5 HT, $11.5 P

  • Abruzzese

    House-made pizza sauce, mozzarella, house-made meatballs, sliced roasted garlic, parsley, Parmesan, Romano

    $17 HT, $12.5 P, $24 S

  • Carne

    House-made pizza sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, sweet fennel sausage, Genoa salami, Parmesan, Romano

    $17 HT, $12.5 P, $24 S

  • Funghi

    Portabello, shiitake, fancy white and oyster mushrooms in a white wine cream sauce, fontina, Parmesan, Romano, parsley

    $17 HT, $12.5 P, $24 S

  • Bianca

    Ricotta, fontina, Parmesan, Romano, mozzarella, plum tomatoes, sliced roasted garlic

    $15 HT, $12 P, $22 S

  • Vedure Arrosto

    House-made pizza sauce, mozzarella, Parmesan, Romano, roasted vegetables: eggplant, zucchini, yellow squash, red onion, red peppers

    $16 HT, $12.5 P, $23 S

  • Scampi

    Garlic butter, mozzarella, Parmesan, Romano, fontina, shrimp, roasted shallots, parsley

    $17.5 HT, $14 P

  • BBQ Chicken or Tempeh

    Sweet BBQ and house-made pizza sauce, chicken breast or tempeh, red onion, mozzarella, smoked Gouda, cilantro

    $17 HT, $12.5 P, $24 S

  • Lombardo

    Fresh mozzarella, Parmesan, Romano, prosciutto, arugula, extra virgin olive oil, Grana Padano

    $17.00

Create Your Own Pizza

1. Choose your dough: Start with our hand-tossed dough, 100% whole milk Grande mozzarella, and one of our house-made sauces, then get creative. (We recommend no more than 3-4 toppings to ensure proper cooking)

Hand Tossed pizzas are 12” crispy and hand-crafted (8 slices, serves 1–2)

Sicilian pizzas are thick crust, pan pizzas and require a longer cooking time (12 slices, serves 3–4)

Pizzetta is an 8” hand tossed personal pizza

Udi’s Gluten-Free 12“, contains eggs (8 slices, serves 1-2)

Cauliflower 10” Gluten-free, contains dairy (8 slices, personal pizza)

Calzone 12”

2. Choose your sauce house-made pizza sauce, vegan marinara, pesto, herbed garlic butter, ricotta, BBQ, buffalo

3. Choose your toppings – ask your server to see a list of our premium, fresh options (all priced individually)

Pasta

From traditional to modern, our pastas are crafted by our cooks using the freshest ingredients in every dish, every day. All pastas are served with garlic bread

  • Pappardelle Bolognese

    Slow-cooked Bolognese made with beef & pork, cream, Parmesan Romano

    $19.00

  • Mama Josephine Spaghetti and Meatballs (named after my mom)

    Meatballs made with beef & pork, marinara

    $16.50

  • Penne alla Pesto

    Penne, chicken breast, sun-dried tomatoes, pesto, white wine cream sauce, Grana Padano, pine nuts

    $18.00

  • Spaghetti Carbonara

    Spaghetti, bacon, onion, cream, Parmesan, Romano

    $18.00

  • Fettuccine Alfredo

    House-made Alfredo sauce; Add Chicken 4 Add Shrimp 4

    $14.00

Desserts

  • Italian Chocolate Budino

    Homemade Italian pudding topped with whipped cream and crushed amaretto cookies

    $8.00

  • Key Lime Tart

    House-made Key lime tart, buttery graham cracker crust and whipped cream

    $8.00

  • Cannoli

    Crispy pastry shell filled with house-made sweetened ricotta and chocolate chips

    $4.75
  • “So great! We had the cauliflower crust and it was perfect...we're still talking about how good the pizza was! Great and quick service.”
    Lindsey Roberts
  • “Such an amazing spot. The Micanopy salad and bbq chicken pizza are my faves. I’ve had many sweet family dinners here. Love Blue Highway!”
    Sarah Hinds
  • “
    This is the best pizza in or around Gainesville! The staff is always so friendly and they make delicious cannoli!
    ”
    Brooke Nantz
  • “Ordered 10 pizzas for pickup. Order was on time & perfect! Every single one delicious! Fungi is our new favorite 🤩”
    Amber Young Parker